Manchester City challenge £830m funding findings as sanctions await separate hearing

Manchester City have been found to have breached Premier League financial rules through arrangements that concealed more than £830m in funding, according to BBC Sport's reporting of an independent commission's findings. The league published a redacted report on Tuesday, 29 September. City reject the findings, maintain their innocence and say they will pursue an appeal.

Watch the highlights:

The commission upheld all charges concerning financial-rule breaches between the 2009-10 and 2017-18 seasons, the BBC reported. It also upheld all but one of the charges concerning non-cooperation with the league's investigation. The report described a system of commercial agreements that misrepresented the club's income and expenditure, with the disguised funding calculated at £830.69m.

Sponsorship income was a central element of the findings. Across City's title-winning seasons of 2011-12, 2013-14 and 2017-18, the club recorded £360m in sponsor fees. According to the BBC's account of the ruling, only £43m was legitimate sponsorship revenue; the remainder came from the owners but was presented as commercial income. The commission concluded that the agreements did not reflect the underlying financial reality.

The findings extended beyond the accounting treatment of those payments. The commission said important club witnesses had provided false evidence on significant matters, with some doing so knowingly. It also concluded that the arrangements enabled City to avoid reporting what would otherwise have been the Premier League's largest single-season loss in 2009-10. Its evidence index exceeded 750 pages, illustrating the volume of material considered.

City responded by challenging the commission's conclusions and the basis of its decision. In a statement reported by the BBC, the club said evidence supported its position and argued that the ruling contained substantial legal and factual errors. It intends to use the available appeal procedures and has until 2 October to submit an appeal. The club also stressed that significant parts of the process remain unfinished.

No sanction was announced with the published findings. The Premier League said punishment would be considered at a separate hearing before the independent commission, with its rules requiring those proceedings to remain confidential. League chief executive Richard Masters defended the decision to pursue the case and the importance of enforcing club-approved rules. For now, the findings, City's intended appeal and the unresolved sanction remain distinct stages of the proceedings.